The Church choir in its current configuration was started about 1985 when Barbara Pfeil gathered together members who liked to sing. For several years, we rehearsed and performed without a conductor. When Ede Thomas moved to Brattleboro full time, she became choir director. Shortly after that, Nancy Reed moved to town and became the accompanist. Nancy brought a portable organ to the building and played that as well. She and Ede took turns directing the choir. There were a number of skilled singers, especially Tommie Thomas and Jack Reed.
Over the years, in addition to singing a weekly anthem at All Souls Church, members have participated in town wide events and ecumenical services. Tom Baehr has been the director since September 2014. He has presided over virtual rehearsals and recorded anthems during the pandemic era.